Skip to content

P7: pre-submission reviewer iteration 3 under the denolle profile #45

Open

Description

@mdenolle

Package P7 of the iteration-3 plan: run the pre-submission reviewer again. Owner: agent. Size: hours. Blocked by the merge of #38 to #44 (P5 and P6 may lag; say so in the run).

  • Run the reviewer in reconciliation mode under profiles/denolle.md (the author profile created 2026-09-11) with a diff against commit c10a108 (the iteration-2 baseline); the ledger is reviews/codameter-gji.review.json at iteration 2 (62 prior and introduced entries plus AUTH-01).
  • Every prior finding gets exactly one verdict with cited changed text; new findings only on changed spans; the two buckets stay separate.
  • Write the updated manifest (iteration 3, history appended), the report, and the readiness delta; do not hand-edit statuses.
  • Expected exit criterion for submission: no Poor entry open; C2, C3, C4 at Good; the archive and end-matter gates met.

Working agreement (agents and humans). One PR per issue, branch iter3/<package> off docs/sign-convention-manuscript; name the ledger IDs in the PR title; request Copilot review before approval. Do not edit review/REVISION_PLAN_ITER3.md except to tick boxes and append a dated log line naming this issue. Do not hand-edit statuses in reviews/codameter-gji.review.json; the reviewer reconciles them in P7. Tests and pre-commit hooks must pass. Before requesting review, rebuild the PDF (cd paper && ../.pixi/envs/dev/bin/python build.py --no-survey) and check its text for ??, ,%, << and [Funding. Evidence for every finding: reviews/iter2/block_S-*.md; full report reviews/codameter-gji.iter2.report.md; plan review/REVISION_PLAN_ITER3.md.

Activity

  1. added this to the Iteration 3 revision milestone on Sep 11, 2026
  2. added
    P7reviewer iteration 3
    agent-readyself-contained; a CLI agent can take it
    review-iter2from the iteration-2 pre-submission review
    on Sep 11, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    P7reviewer iteration 3agent-readyself-contained; a CLI agent can take itreview-iter2from the iteration-2 pre-submission review

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions